Comment: "Good quality yarn with a good quality dye job, i.e., not some horribly failed experiment, but that's a given"
I don't feel that the yarn she sent was anywhere near a good quality dye job. Although she did send excess yarn and did also avoid sending wool (I think), I couldn't give her a 5 for this swap - sorry.
Response: Sorry-since I dye mainly wool my hands were sort of tied.